A comparison of socialist morality in star wars and star trek

Star trek shows you how things work it takes some pains to create believable rules around its technology and the universe the characters inhabit star wars doesn't seem to bother at all it's fantasy adventure in star trek, whole storylines have been created around engineering puzzles, and there is still a. Why the difference i suspect that, although star trek is addictive (to judge from its audience and my own experience), it is also, relative to star wars, politically liberal, morally serious, and in its best episodes so much less addictive than most of the tv competition that the idea-men of the industry — the front office producers. Star trek sometimes catches flack for portraying a socialist space utopia there's a vast replicator technology would enable the utopia of the star trek universe by eliminating physical scarcity of most things even energy scarcity isn't and there is never a bit of moral ambiguity in their decision these themes come to.

Endless money: the moral hazards of socialism [william baker, addison wiggin] on amazoncom free shipping on qualifying offers a detailed look at how, and why, the american financial system has reached its current state today's economy and capital markets are faced with the long-term buildup of public and. Part one of (eventually) two, i examine the different moral philosophies that separate and define these two franchises patreon page: com. Star trek preferred to explore moral questions in a futuristic setting – it was closer to shakespeare's the tempest than attack of the 50 foot woman critics were divided over its september 8, 1966 debut the new york times called it an “ astronautical soap opera that suffers from interminable flight drag. Star trek tos patterns of force spock meets the deputy fuhrer in star wars episode viii: the last jedi we find out kylo ren didn't murder his father because han made one too many dad jokes when he was growing up in fact people used to compare him to a star trek hero rather than a star wars villain, i think.

That embrace is one small but crucial mission accomplished for cbs, which with “discovery” is bringing “star trek” back to television 12 years after the last already she grabs hold of the central themes of “star trek” and hoists them up as important ideals — a mix of moral philosophy and fan service. The development of star trek's moral and political tone over 50 years traces the strange decline of american liberalism since the kennedy era roddenberry and his colleagues were world war ii veterans, whose country was now fighting the cold war against a communist aggressor they regarded with. Star trek: first contact mpaa rating: pg-13-rating (mpaa) for some sci-fi adventure violence reviewed by: ken james staff writer moral rating: average moviemaking quality: i think a comparison of the borg queen to god could spur a marvelous conversation about reality and theology for those of you who.

These are genres that have traditionally provided fertile ground for metaphysically inclined fiction, but for a long time their presence in the american mass media began with star trek and ended with star wars—fun but shallow entertainments whose take on religion mixed daniel dennett with deepak. The article claims almost every modern epic – superhero movies, star wars, harry potter, lord of the rings, etc – shares a similar plot there are some compare to ancient myths, where hector defecting to greece because the abduction of helen was morally wrong is just totally unthinkable this is a. On friday, star trek: discovery writer and supervising producer ted sullivan announced that he (along with fellow writer kirsten beyer) was headed back trek fans take note: sam witwer, who asked the ships question, has some high- end sci-fi cred with appearances & voicework on star trek, star wars,.

The members of the starship enterprise reflect personal struggles of moral justice , often helping one another to discover the best possible solution it is sci-fi at its best, laying the groundwork for movies such as star wars to even exist ( although sw is sophomoric at most in comparison) star trek is driven. One of the biggest (and perhaps somewhat controversial) pieces of star wars news to come out recently was the reveal that jj abrams would be returning to direct episode ix abrams also directed the first of the new trilogy, episode vii: the force awakens (with rian johnson directing the upcoming.

A comparison of socialist morality in star wars and star trek

Star trek and star wars present alternative scenarios of space adventure the two streams are dominant in this setting of storytelling and have offered various forms of media productions for decades that manage billions of dollars of intellectual property, providing employment and entertainment for billions of people around. Saraumanic heroes: the ethics of star wars by gwydion m williams the bad and the half-good sympathy and duty the bad and the half-good star wars opens as if c-3po was going to be the main character this is comparing dune and the start of the luke trilogy, i have to wonder if 'spice' once play a larger role.

  • Nerds can't stop fighting over which is better, star wars or star trek including the star wars prequels and jj abrams' 2015 flick, that makes seven in-cannon movies throw a few but when you compare the win/loss columns of both franchises, star trek easily comes out on top with way more good stuff than bad.
  • Hollywood films and religion have an ongoing rocky relationship, especially in the realm of science fiction a brief comparison study of the two giants of mainstream sci-fi, star wars and star trek reveals the differing attitudes toward religion humanism and socialist collectivist values these values were.
  • Also in slate, matthew yglesias ranks every star trek movie, television series, villain, and crew member in the the federation, which our beloved crew serves, is engaged in something like a cold war with the klingon empire we also see the practical operation of a post-scarcity socialist economy.

The tantive iv corvette is 150 meters in length, to give a visual comparison in the star trek universe, warp ten is the limit (although there are instances of ships traveling much faster) the use of hyperspace allowed the star wars universe to forego warp technology, so the federation has that edge. There have been many comparisons between star trek and its chief competitor for the hearts of science fiction fandom -- star wars viewed through the optimistic lens of what we know about the trek universe now, earth of the time is a democratic socialist paradise, but the story would work just as. The epic space saga star wars has elements for both liberals and conservatives most of us can agree what is right and what is wrong most of us can look at the big picture and come together around a shared moral and ethical code but when we speak about politics, we get heated, we get passionate,.

a comparison of socialist morality in star wars and star trek I'm a capitalist 'star wars' is the capitalist show 'star trek' is the communist one,” he told dowd “there is no money in 'star trek' because you just have the transporter machine that can make anything you need,” he added “the whole plot. a comparison of socialist morality in star wars and star trek I'm a capitalist 'star wars' is the capitalist show 'star trek' is the communist one,” he told dowd “there is no money in 'star trek' because you just have the transporter machine that can make anything you need,” he added “the whole plot.
A comparison of socialist morality in star wars and star trek
Rated 5/5 based on 12 review